Note that USAA ranked in the first or second spot in almost all cities, but we've excluded them from this table because the company only serves military and affiliated members. Below is also a deeper dive by the largest cities of the most affordable insurers by age and marital status to give drivers a further idea of the going rates for auto insurance. We've excluded USAA from the city specific tables as well.
Every year a few weeks before your car insurance is due to expire you will receive a renewal quotation, usually with a letter that tells you that you don’t need to do anything as your policy will be automatically renewed and your payment will be taken by direct debit, if you have set this up previously. They may ask you to call them to renew your policy so that you can make a payment if you don’t have direct debit set up. Whatever you do, don’t think that because they offered you a great deal one year, that they will do it continuously year after year. This is absolutely not the case. Some very cheap car insurance companies will creep up their premiums year after year, relying on the insured being either to busy, or to lazy to check out what other insurers have to offer them. Always come back to a comparison site to see what the latest deals are. Almost every time you will get yourself a better deal. My advice would be to don’t give that company a second chance by allowing them to match your new best quote. Keep them on their toes by just taking out your new policy. If more people were to do this then perhaps in the future more very cheap motor insurance companies will try a little harder to keep loyal customers , by truly giving them their best very cheap car insurance prices they can at that time.
I had Allstate for over 20 years and it just kept going up. I would contact my agent to see if anything could be saved and they would adjust it slightly each year, but it was over $200 per month and I had a perfect driving record, and my vehicles were getting older and older. Finally I was fed up and got quotes from nearly a dozen insurers and Esurance beat them all, lowering my payments by more than HALF! Now I'm worried, though, since Allstate has now purchased Esurance. Will my rates start to go up and up again? Time will tell.
Being in the business for a very long time, I have found that most people are clueless about insurance, even most agents who sell them. I will agree that their rates are cheap. But I wouldn’t recommend them. Inexperienced adjusters. They do not fully investigate. The policy does not cover like, kind, and quality which is bad if you have a new vehicle.